Wednesday, November 27, 2013
Free Lunch
Sorry this photo became skewed. I lifted it off the Internets. Anyway, the photo is the closest I could find to the lunch plates that were used when I was in grade school.
I am having a hard time deciding if I am going to post about this topic or not. Thirty, twenty and even ten years ago I would never have considered it. I try not to talk about these things.
For many reason. First and foremost is - I don't want pity. I don't want people to think I want pity, either. That bothers me beyond belief.
But, I read a post today that got me to thinking.
Free lunches, free breakfasts in schools.
So many people say it is a great idea - how nice to help the needy.
Today's kids are different than we were back in the 50's and 60's. In that era it was a SHAME to get a free lunch. Breakfasts were not even considered, yet. My Mom told me that when our brother (1953) signed up for free lunches the teacher would write their names on the chalkboard. That is right. The entire list of students who were to get a free lunch written for all the world to see. The "haves" had a field day teasing the "have nots".
Since that time my Mom never let us sign up for free anything again. She lined up five brown bags (at that time five of us were in school) every morning and we ate a bologna sandwich, one small orange and about three cookies every day. It was twenty years before I could touch bologna again. To this day I won't eat it with mayonnaise. In high school I just did not eat lunch.
And, every time I eat a sandwich or an orange, my stomach wants those three damn cookies. Well, okay - my brain wants the three damn cookies. Funny thing, I never seem to want the orange. My brain is completely satisfied skipping the orange but never the cookies. Sigh.
Anyway, for those that think it is a wonderful idea - it is. But consider this. It ain't so wonderful for the child who gets ridiculed by other students and teachers (OH YES THEY DO) when you are getting something free. There is always a teacher or two who believe she is paying for your lunch right out of her pocket and she wants to make certain that you are aware of where that money (lunch) is coming from.
A co-worker told me a story her daughter shared about just such an incident. This incident (which I hope my co-worker reported to the school superintendent) was about her daughter sitting with a friend at lunch. The friend had chosen a salad for lunch. A teacher came up behind the child and snapped "You better eat ALL that salad because I paid for it! Why didn't you get a peanut butter sandwich or something?" TRUE! As if to say that the free loaders need only have a bland sandwich and were not entitled to a more healthy fresh salad as privileged children are. My friend's daughter was confused. She asked her Mom why the teacher paid for her friends' lunches. I don't recall how my co-worker handled the question. She is a wonderful and bright lady, so I am certain her daughter learned something valuable that day.
2013 folks. It is alive and well in our schools today. Shame on the children of the lousy free loaders!
In the post I read I came across the word discrete. The free food is given to the students in need discretely. Really? Does a machine give them the food? Because if there is a human handing out that free food there is always going to be talk. That human tells another human who gets the free lunches. Really - they do. They can't seem to help themselves. Pretty soon a dozen people now know who gets free hand outs. And if even one person has a chip on their shoulder about a family getting free stuff because the father is no good (must be his wife's fault) then it all comes pouring out.
My older sister and brother tell me stories of their youth. Before they became old enough to help the family begin to stand on our own and not rely on hand outs. My father was a drunk. There, I said it. He barely worked. My Mom had 8 children. She was not able to work outside the home, although she did get flack from the welfare agency as to why she thought she could not work and provide for her family and of course they made her feel like it was her fault that my dad was a drunk, etc..
That stopped the welfare. My Mom refused to go back. My older brother joined the Air Force and began sending money home. My older sister put herself through college, worked two jobs and paid the bills with the help from my older brother. They are still close today and live together and help each other. And they still hand money out to the siblings that just keep asking for it. Sigh. I don't know why. It is ingrained in them, I suppose.
Enough of that. It makes me want to vomit just re-reading what I wrote. If you do comment, please do not comment about that. Thanks.
Back to discrete and human nature. I worked as a data entry operator in the early 80's. The business was food distribution to schools, hospitals, nursing homes, bars and diners. At one point a saleslady came up to me with an order and she said "This order is for the shelter for abused and battered women." She said "You know where it is, don't you?" And before I could utter no or any other word she proceeded to tell me where this shelter was. I did NOT need to know. I was not the driver or delivery person. Sheesh. Why couldn't she have kept her mouth shut? Then I began thinking about all the people who actually knew where the shelter is physically located - and then how safe is that? Every policeman would know. The fire department would know. The creepy truck drivers we employed would know. The sleazy salesmen we have would all have know. Discrete my ass. Sorry. No such thing.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

7 comments:
Lots of truth in your post. In my grandgirls' grade school though nearly 90% of the kids were on the free lunch program. It's close to 80% in the other grade schools. That's due to living in a town with minimum wage jobs, think tourist industry. Work hard and can't feed your kids. Hopefully the sheer numbers of children on it will protect them a little, such a rough world for children.
All of the schools my daughter went to were mostly free or reduced lunches. Throughout the years she has been on both with only a short period being on full pay. She was never made to feel less than. I'm not even so sure that her younger years, she knew she was getting free lunch. If the majority of kids are getting it, I don't think they can be singled out and bullied, because they are in the majority now.
A teacher who would make a comment like that to a child shouldn't be teaching.
It's hard enough to be hungry. To be hungry and shamed for it, because of what you cannot control, is unconscionable.
I, like you, came from a family of five kids and one income...we ate a LOT of baloney sandwiches, piece of fruit and a cookie. When you are hungry you don't notice much. I think that there is nothing worse than denigrating a child for their basic needs. But that says a lot more about the person who feels it is necessary to make a child feel smaller! What you feel as shame, all others (99%) see as strength and character and honesty and insight..really! Happy Thanksgiving!
I did want to mention that schools get money for each child that gets free or reduced lunch so now they (the administration)encourage it. Not like the older days when they looked down on it.
And Tabor, you are right. It does build strength and character.
Grumpy - there are quite a few out there who have no business being a teacher.
Good post and shame on the 'discrete' or the deluded teachers out there -- WTF are they doing 'molding' young minds?! And p.s. LOL re the cookie comment. My brain 'wants' cookies whether I need them or not regardless of ingrained behavior...
Post a Comment